I would nominate JMU’s Mike Houston’s call for a Fake Punt in the 2018 Playoff game vs. Colgate. Tie game @ 20-20 with 4th & 5 @ Colgate’s 41 & 2:36 to play. Just pin ‘em deep & give your D a chance to hold ‘em there & get the ball back in FG range or play for OT. The only reason Colgate was in the game was JMU had thrown 5 interceptions & JMU’s D had just held Colgate to only 7 total yards on their preceding 4 possessions. Instead, Colgate stuffed the fake punt, moved the ball 40 yards, and kicked a last second FG to advance...and to advance Coach Houston’s career on to FBS @ ECU.

I thought this was the worst Coaching decision I would see for quite a while, until later that night in the SEC Championship Game, Georgia’s Kirby Smart, said, “Mike...hold my beer.”