With a tip of the cap to OL FU and Mountaineer for putting together the info in this thread for 2010 and previous years I added totals for the last 7 years.

I used Mountaineer's point system:

A first round game is worth 5 points.
A second round game is worth 10 points.
A quarterfinal game is worth 15 points.
A semifinal game is worth 20 points.
A championship game is worth 25 points.
Winning the championship game is worth an additional 25 points.

Therefore the totals that could be earned throughout the years are as follows:

1978 - 1980: Semis/Finals (4 Teams) - 70 Points
1981 - Quarters/Semis/Finals (8 Teams) - 85 Points
1982 - 1985: First/Quarters/Semis/Finals (12 Teams) - 95 Points
1986 - 2009: First/Quarters/Semis/Finals (16 Teams) - 95 Points
2010 - 2012: First/Second/Quarters/Semis/Finals (20 Teams) - 100 Points
2013 - present: First/Second/Quarters/Semis/Finals (24 Teams) - 100 Points

I included the teams no longer classified in the subdivision in the list but denoted them in italics and with an asterisk.

All that said here's how the 109 teams that have participated in the FCS/D1AA playoffs stack up:

Rank Team Points
1 Georgia Southern* 1060
2 Montana 875
3 Youngstown State 695
4 Appalachian State* 655
5 North Dakota State 645
6 Delaware 590
7 Eastern Kentucky 565
8 Northern Iowa 560
9 Marshall* 540
10 Furman 535
11 James Madison 435
12 Sam Houston State 415
13 Eastern Washington 410
14 McNeese 360
T15 New Hampshire 350
T15 Richmond 350
17 Villanova 325
18 UMass* 290
19 Nevada* 270
20 Southern Illinois 245
21 Boise State* 230
22 Western Kentucky* 225
T23 Eastern Illinois 210
T23 Idaho 210
T23 Lehigh 210
T23 Montana State 210
T23 William & Mary 210
28 Illinois State 205
29 Wofford 200
T30 Stephen F Austin 195
T30 Western Illinois 195
32 Colgate 190
T33 Florida A&M 180
T33 Middle Tennessee* 180
35 Jacksonville State 165
36 Troy* 155
37 ULM* 140
T38 Arkansas State* 135
T38 Jackson State 135
40 South Dakota State 130
41 Tennessee State 120
T42 Louisiana Tech* 115
T42 Maine 115
44 Northwestern State 110
45 Weber State 105
46 Idaho State 95
T47 Coastal Carolina* 90
T47 South Carolina State 90
49 Rhode Island 85
T50 Boston U* 80
T50 Hofstra* 80
T50 Towson 80
53 Murray State 75
T54 Fordham 70
T54 Samford 70
T54 The Citadel 70
T54 Western Carolina 70
T58 Chattanooga 65
T58 Indiana State 65
T58 Northern Arizona 65
61 North Carolina A&T 60
T62 North Texas* 55
T62 Texas State* 55
T62 UCF* 55
T65 Cal Poly 50
T65 Central Arkansas 50
T65 Hampton 50
T65 Nicholls 50
T69 Alcorn State 45
T69 Bethune-Cookman 45
T69 Florida Atlantic* 45
T69 Stony Brook 45
T73 Grambling State 40
T73 Old Dominion* 40
T75 Holy Cross 35
T75 Lafayette 35
T75 Missouri State 35
T75 San Diego 35
T79 Charleston Southern 30
T79 Kennesaw State 30
T79 Southeastern Louisiana 30
T82 Connecticut* 25
T82 East Tennessee State 25
T84 Portland State 20
T84 Southern Utah 20
T86 Elon 15
T86 Liberty* 15
T86 South Dakota 15
T86 Southeast Missouri State 15
T86 Wagner 15
T91 Akron* 10
T91 Delaware State 10
T91 Howard 10
T91 Mississippi Valley State 10
T91 North Dakota 10
T91 Northeastern* 10
T91 Sacred Heart 10
T91 UT Martin 10
T99 Albany 5
T99 Butler 5
T99 Central Connecticut State 5
T99 Dayton 5
T99 Duquesne 5
T99 Monmouth 5
T99 Morgan State 5
T99 Norfolk State 5
T99 Robert Morris 5
T99 Saint Francis (PA) 5
T99 Tennessee Tech 5