Who is /was better Armani Edwards or Vad Lee?

[whoanellie]

Compare or contrast?

[DatDude]

Who has the most FCS championships and had a career in the NFL????xcoffeex

[Professor Chaos]

Who has the most FCS championships and had a career in the NFL????xcoffeex
Kyle Emanuel???

[dewey]

Who is Armani Edwards, LOL!!!

Do you mean Armanti Edwards
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armanti_Edwards:D

Dewey

[BEAR]

Giorgio...you know....GIORGIO!


http://www.vogue.fr/uploads/images/thumbs/201234/giorgio_armani_854_north_990x.jpg

[phoenix3]

Who has the most FCS championships and had a career in the NFL????xcoffeex

I don't know if I would call that a "career" in the NFL.

[jmufan999]

Compare or contrast?

what are your thoughts?

[JMU2K_DukeDawg]

They are different players. I see Vad as a more powerful runner, but maybe a step slower. Vad is an average passer, good arm strength, but "meh" on reading defenses and making the right decisions. Rodney Landers by contrast from JMU in 2008 was an even stronger runner but even more mediocre in the passing game.

AE was complete - runner and passer. Vad is too, but he is now a senior, a transfer from GT after his sophomore season, and it took him a half of a season last year to get into his groove at JMU in a different system. There's just not enough there to fairly compare.

Bottom line, AE won three NCs. The debate pretty much ends there in terms of accomplishments. However, Vad may get a closer look by NFL teams than AE did due to being a bit bigger in size. I could see him as a cheap third string QB for the Vikings behind Teddy Bridgewater (Shaun Hill [UMD] and Taylor Heinicke [ODU] are current backups).

[AshevilleApp2]

xlolx

[JMU2004]

Edwards....back to back NCs. Still remember the 2006 game at App when he came in to the game. Our players said he was way better than the QB App started.

[Catsfan90]

I am more of a Ralph Lauren kinda guy myself. xcoolx

[veinup]

spell the dudes name right bro

and the answer is ARMANTI edwards.

[BEAR]

My vote is for Armondo Edwardson. His game against Minnesota Maize and blue is the all time upset in college football. That or he just didn't participate in that "hot, hot, hot" video. xthumbsupx

[whoanellie]

I just know that they BOTH have completely worn us out when they played us. It was a shame the Panthers
drafted up to get him and then did nothing with him.

[BisonFan02]

This question is invalid...the correct answer is Brock Jensen. xlolx

[KPSUL]

spell the dudes name right bro

and the answer is ARMANTI edwards.

dude's not dudes.

[clenz]

dude's not dudes.
That's funny. Also same guy that went NIU and not UNI today.

The internet is fun

[Apphole]

I just know that they BOTH have completely worn us out when they played us. It was a shame the Panthers
drafted up to get him and then did nothing with him.
He might have had a shot at PR and WR if not for Elon going after his knees with the coaches blessing every year.

[veinup]

sorry i left out the proper punctuation you guy's

[penguinpower]

There have only been 3 true freshman QB's to win a national championship in college football at the division 1 level (not sure about D2 and D3) and Armanti Edwards was one of them. Anyone care to guess the other two?

[penguinpower]

There have only been 3 true freshman QB's to win a national championship in college football at the division 1 level (not sure about D2 and D3) and Armanti Edwards was one of them. I would have to say that he is better due to this fact. Anyone care to guess the other two?

[penguinpower]

Weird........that posted twice.

[Grizalltheway]

Edwards came to Missoula and damn near beat a Griz team that went 14-1. And the national titles.

[BigHouseClosedEnd]

Based on resume, this isn't close because Edwards had the most impressive resume in FCS history.

That said, if we're talking about the highest level that an FCS player has played, Lee may make a compelling case by the time this season is over. He has less talent around him that AE did. He's also a better passer.

[uni88]

Tracy Ham.

[BisonFan02]

There have only been 3 true freshman QB's to win a national championship in college football at the division 1 level (not sure about D2 and D3) and Armanti Edwards was one of them. I would have to say that he is better due to this fact. Anyone care to guess the other two?

NDSU's Jeff Bentrim

http://www.footballfoundation.org/Programs/CollegeFootballHallofFame/SearchDetail.aspx?id=80012

Watch for good ol' number uno. :D


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0VEBJbbTu4g

[BucBisonAtLarge]

Way too early for this stuff...

[Bill]

There have only been 3 true freshman QB's to win a national championship in college football at the division 1 level (not sure about D2 and D3) and Armanti Edwards was one of them. I would have to say that he is better due to this fact. Anyone care to guess the other two?

Jamelle Holloway (sorry if spelled wrong)...he took over after Troy Aikman broke his leg at OU...rest is history.

[Go Lehigh TU owl]

Vad Lee is currently being profiled on Sports Center! Pretty sweet!

[CID1990]

I don't know if I would call that a "career" in the NFL.

If a career in the NFL is the metric then Andre Roberts is better than both of them.

[Demwai]

If a career in the NFL is the metric then Andre Roberts is better than both of them.

Steve McNair was better than them all and it's not even close...

[MR. CHICKEN]

........FLACCO!...........'NUFF SAID.............BROCK!

[ElonFirefighter]

Who has the most FCS championships and had a career in the NFL????xcoffeex


NFL Career???? Edwards as the water boy???

http://www.zuguide.com/images/14814/14814.0.570.359.jpg

[penguinpower]

Bernie Kosar (University of Miami)
Armanti Edwards (Appalachian State)
Jamis Winston (Florida State)

[thebootfitter]

........FLACCO!...........'NUFF SAID.............BROCK!
I agree with both Flacco and Brock. Good post!

[BisonFan02]

I agree with both Flacco and Brock. Good post!

What you did there......I see it. :D

[BisonFan02]

When someone asks about your favorite team's 3 time national championship winning QB...and you get to ask "which one?".....#NDSUfirstworldproblems

[blueballs]

Armanti Edwards... the only thing that could stop him was a lawnmower.

[Sycamore62]

Armani, Armanti who gives a ****

[ElonFirefighter]

Armanti Edwards... the only thing that could stop him was a lawnmower.

After his stent in the NFL he went to the Mexican National league but was mowed down week 1 by the Dline