AGS Top 25 - How They Fared - Week 7

[smilo]

Just looked up the criteria.

Any way you slice it, SIU has got to be considered a good win for EIU and YSU.

[Engineer86]

Just looked up the criteria.

Any way you slice it, SIU has got to be considered a good win for EIU and YSU.

Where did you find the criteria. I looked at the original post and didn't see anything that would outline a good win or bad loss at this point.

[ursus arctos horribilis]

Where did you find the criteria. I looked at the original post and didn't see anything that would outline a good win or bad loss at this point.

I gave you the exact way to find it a few posts back there. The search function is your friend E86.

http://www.anygivensaturday.com/show...s%2Fbad+losses

[superman7515]

Just looked up the criteria.

Any way you slice it, SIU has got to be considered a good win for EIU and YSU.

3-3 against D1 competition. Two wins against good teams and two losses against good teams, one loss to a FBS school which doesn't count against them, one win against a terrible team which doesn't count for them = Not a good win for EIU and YSU.

[Engineer86]

I gave you the exact way to find it a few posts back there. The search function is your friend E86.

http://www.anygivensaturday.com/show...s%2Fbad+losses

Yes you did. I searched it and readthe entire thread, you must not have, and there is nothing in there that would answer the question I asked. I see that Supe has responded with what I was looking for.

[Engineer86]

3-3 against D1 competition. Two wins against good teams and two losses against good teams, one loss to a FBS school which doesn't count against them, one win against a terrible team which doesn't count for them = Not a good win for EIU and YSU.

If SUI is not a good win, yet wins over Alabama St is for two teams, Alcorn St as well? Does not pass the sniff test. I was thinking there was more thought to it. Still appreciate the effort.

[Houndawg]

3-3 against D1 competition. Two wins against good teams and two losses against good teams, one loss to a FBS school which doesn't count against them, one win against a terrible team which doesn't count for them = Not a good win for EIU and YSU.

I dunno, two road wins against Top 10 teams on their homecomings, two losses by 1 pt and by 3 in 2OT against rated teams indicates a legit squad, imo, especially if SOS counts this year.

[ursus arctos horribilis]

Yes you did. I searched it and readthe entire thread, you must not have, and there is nothing in there that would answer the question I asked. I see that Supe has responded with what I was looking for.

Ok, I assumed you were still looking for the thread (criteria) so my mistake.

[superman7515]

If SUI is not a good win, yet wins over Alabama St is for two teams, Alcorn St as well? Does not pass the sniff test. I was thinking there was more thought to it. Still appreciate the effort.

It's a work in progress, I'm still trying to figure out a way to do it fairly. If it was completely my own thoughts, no win over an Ivy, PFL, or SWAC team would be good, and every loss to an Ivy, PFL or SWAC team would be bad. Same for any team in the Patriot this season not named Fordham or Lehigh.