With a tip of the cap to OL FU and Mountaineer for putting together the info in this thread for 2010 and previous years I added totals for the last 8 years.

I used Mountaineer's point system:

A first round game is worth 5 points.
A second round game is worth 10 points.
A quarterfinal game is worth 15 points.
A semifinal game is worth 20 points.
A championship game is worth 25 points.
Winning the championship game is worth an additional 25 points.

Therefore the totals that could be earned throughout the years are as follows:

1978 - 1980: Semis/Finals (4 Teams) - 70 Points
1981 - Quarters/Semis/Finals (8 Teams) - 85 Points
1982 - 1985: First/Quarters/Semis/Finals (12 Teams) - 95 Points
1986 - 2009: First/Quarters/Semis/Finals (16 Teams) - 95 Points
2010 - 2012: First/Second/Quarters/Semis/Finals (20 Teams) - 100 Points
2013 - present: First/Second/Quarters/Semis/Finals (24 Teams) - 100 Points

Here's a look at the current top 25:

Rank Teams Points W L WinPct Apps Titles
1 Georgia Southern 1060 45 13 77.6% 19 6
2 Montana 875 34 22 60.7% 24 2
3 North Dakota State 740 32 2 94.1% 9 7
4 Youngstown State 695 29 8 78.4% 12 4
5 Appalachian State 650 24 17 58.5% 20 3
6 Delaware 580 22 15 59.5% 16 1
7 Northern Iowa 565 24 20 54.5% 20
8 Eastern Kentucky 555 16 19 45.7% 21 2
9 Marshall 540 23 6 79.3% 8 2
10 Furman 515 19 16 54.3% 17 1
11 Eastern Washington 475 19 12 61.3% 13 1
12 James Madison 450 17 13 56.7% 15 2
13 Sam Houston State 415 19 11 63.3% 11
14 McNeese 360 11 16 40.7% 16
15 Richmond 350 15 10 60.0% 11 1
16 New Hampshire 345 14 16 46.7% 16
17 Villanova 320 12 11 52.2% 12 1
18 Massachusetts 290 10 7 58.8% 8 1
19 Nevada 260 9 7 56.3% 7
20 Southern Illinois 235 8 7 53.3% 8 1
21 Boise State 230 8 4 66.7% 5 1
22 Western Kentucky 225 8 7 53.3% 8 1
23 Colgate 215 7 11 38.9% 11
24T Eastern Illinois 210 4 16 20.0% 16
24T Idaho 210 6 11 35.3% 11
24T Lehigh 210 6 11 35.3% 11
24T Montana State 210 7 8 46.7% 9 1
24T Wofford 210 9 9 50.0% 9



For grins here's what the top 25 looked like 10 years ago (after the 2008 season):

Rank Teams Points W L WinPct Apps Titles
1 Georgia Southern 920 38 10 79.2% 16 6
2 Montana 720 27 17 61.4% 19 2
3 Youngstown State 620 25 7 78.1% 11 4
4 Appalachian State 560 25 7 78.1% 16 3
5 Eastern Kentucky 545 16 17 48.5% 19 2
6 Marshall 540 23 6 79.3% 8 2
7 Delaware 505 19 13 59.4% 14 1
8 Furman 485 17 14 54.8% 15 1
9 Northern Iowa 460 18 14 56.3% 14
10 McNeese 330 11 13 45.8% 13
11 Massachusetts 290 10 7 58.8% 8 1
12 Nevada 260 9 7 56.3% 7
13 James Madison 240 8 8 50.0% 9 1
14 Richmond 235 9 6 60.0% 7 1
15 Boise State 230 8 4 66.7% 5 1
16 Western Kentucky 225 8 7 53.3% 8 1
17T Idaho 210 6 11 35.3% 11
17T Southern Illinois 210 7 6 53.8% 7 1
19 Florida A&M 180 5 6 45.5% 7 1
20 Middle Tennessee 170 6 7 46.2% 7
21 Eastern Illinois 165 3 12 20.0% 12
22T Lehigh 160 4 7 36.4% 7
22T Western Illinois 160 5 8 38.5% 8
24T Colgate 155 4 8 33.3% 8
24T Troy 155 5 7 41.7% 7



Similarly here's the top 10 for just the 2010s:

Rank Teams Points W L WinPct Apps Titles
1 North Dakota State 740 32 2 94.1% 9 7
2T Eastern Washington 325 14 5 73.7% 6 1
2T Sam Houston State 325 16 7 69.6% 7
4 James Madison 210 9 5 64.3% 6 1
5 New Hampshire 190 9 8 52.9% 8
6 South Dakota State 165 8 7 53.3% 7
7 Jacksonville State 155 6 7 46.2% 7
8 Georgia Southern 140 7 3 70.0% 3
9 Wofford 130 6 6 50.0% 6
10 Illinois State 125 5 4 55.6% 4



If you're interested I can do a breakdown for each decade or a breakdown for a custom year range. I also have overall conferences numbers in terms of points, win/losses, etc for the current conference teams.